Tennyson by Michael Millgate
Tennyson himself sems to have foreseen this:»Modern fame is nothing», he is reported to have said, «I’d rather have an acre of land. I shall go down, down! I’m up now. Actin and reaction». And so it has been. The reaction began even before Tennyson’s death, as the popularity of Swinburne and other younger poets clearly suggests. After 1892 the reaction became strong and obvious, though it was primarily a reaction against the philosophy and attitudes of Tennyson’s work, its representative Victorian quality, rather than the poetic craftsmanship: Tennyson, as a «nature poet», was still a living influence for the Georgians aven at the moment when his reputation was being involved in that general debunking of the Victorians which culminated in Lytton Strachey’s Eminent Victorians (1918). Tennyson was a philosopher and seer, the supreme interpreter of his age, «the Great Voice of Victorian England».
The ambiguity, however, is itself an indication of the way in which Tennyson’s lack of intelectual strength may actually give his work a special interest for the modern reader, not only because it often reflects so directly, even naïvely, the changing mood of the period (see, for example, such «Laureate» poems as the «Ode sunf at the Opening of the International Exhibition» and the verses «To the Queen» which appear at the end of the Idylls of the King), but also because its constant ambiguity and self-contradiction may serve to direct our attention to the deep divisions and instabilities within the whole Victorian edifice.
God had to exist because without him nothing made sense. There is an unresolved conflict in all of Tennyson’s religious vere from the beginning to the end of his career, and in «The Two Voices» this conflict is explicitly dramatized in the form of a dialogue between tie «I» of the poem, whom it seems safe to identify with the poet, and the bitter voice of disillusionment and despair.
At the end of «The Vision of Sin» we are told that «God made himself an awful rose of dawn»; at the end of «Vastness», a very late poem, the catalogue of negation is closed with the abrupt reversal. In such poems the conflict between the need to believe and the defficulty of believing is all too plain, and Tennyson is see to be clinging almost desperately to the central, indispensable belief taht our life on earth is meaningless without the sum, of his position. He was not concerned to uphold the dogmas of historical Christianity: the concluding stanza of In Memorian, for example, is certainly affirmative but it does not seem to be specifically Christian.
This doctrinal indefiniteness seems not to have troubled Tennyson’s readres. It was enough for them that the poet, while sharing all the dougts and fears of an age shaken by new scientific discoveries, by theories of evolution, by historical crticism of the ible, and by a general collapse of the old religious, ethical, and social certainties, had nevertheless emerged with some kind of rligious conviction atill intact. One of the reasons for the enormous popularity of In Memorian must surely have been the way in which the poet’s religious doubts before being overcome, were given a full and ever eloquent hearing. The poem became a kind of national confessional, with a comfortable absolution at the end.
Tennyson’s great strength, at least in the eyes of his contemporaries, wa the fact that he did not ignore or reject the new theory of evolution nor any of the evidence of modern science.
It is vain to search for Tenyson’s «philosophy», for he did not have one: he never arrived at any coherent system of reasoned attitudes and beliefs. The effect is sometimes valuable, as in the visionary moment so movingly described in section XCV of In Memorian, but often the sense of being on the edge of chaos leads only to an eaggeration of familiar Victorian attitudes: one thinks, for example, of the too-strident patriotism and exaltation of war found in Maud; of his frequent celebrations of Victorian family life and of male superiority; and of his rather chilling insistence on the qualities of «Self-reverence, self-knowledge, self-control» in the presentation of such heroes as King Arthur.
Tennyson’s Ideas and Beliefs
Tennyson himself seems to have foreseen this: «Modern fame is nothing, » he is reported to have said, «I’d rather have an acre of land. I shall go down, down! I’m up now. Action and reaction.» And so it has been. The reaction began even before Tennyson’s death, as the popularity of Swinburne and other younger poets clearly suggests. After 1892 the reaction became strong and obvious, though it was primarily a reaction against the philosophy and attitudes of Tennyson’s work, its representative Victorian quality, rather than the poetic craftsmanship: Tennyson, as a «nature poet», was still a living influence for the Georgians even at the moment when his reputation was being involved in that general debunking of the Victorians which culminated in Lytton Strachey’s Eminent Victorians (1918).
In Tennyson’s religious and philosiphical poems the voice of doubt is always heard, because it was so loud and so insistent that it could not be silenced, yet the poems themselves end almost always on a note of optimism. It was unthinkable, inconceivable, that they should do otherwise. God had to exist because without him nothing made sense. There is an unresolved conflict in all of Tennyson’s religious verse from the beginning to the end of his career, and in «The Two Voices» this conflict is explicitly dramatized in the form of a dialogue between the «I» of the poem, whom it seems safe to identify with the poet, and the bitter voice of disillusionment and despair.
The violence of the reaction against Tenyson derived largely from the fact that Victorian admiration for him had been rooted not so much in appreciation of his distinctive qualities as a poet as in gratitude for the comfort and encouragement he offered as a thinker and teacher. The great weight of Victorian opinion, from T.H. Huxley downwards, concurred in regarding Tennyson as a philosopher and seer, the supreme interpreter of his age, «the Great Voice of Victorian England».
The ambiguity, however, is itself an indeication of the way in which Tennyson’s lack of intellectual strength may actually give his work a special interest for the modern reader, not only because it often reflects so directly, even naïvely, the changing mood of the period (see, for example, such «Laureate» poems as the «Ode sung at the Opening of the International Exhibition» and the verses «To the Queen» which appear at the end of the Idylls of the King), but also because its constant ambiguity and self-contradiction may serve to direct our attention to the deep divisions and instabilities within the whole Victorian edifice.
At the end of «The Vision of Sin» we are told that «God made Himself an awful rose of dawn»; at the end of «Vatness», a very late poem, the catalogue of negations is closed with the abrupt reversal. In such poems the conflict between the need to believe and the difficulty of believing is all too plain, and Tennyson is seen to be clinging almost desperately to the central, indispensable belief taht our life on earth is meningless without the hope of immortality. This is the essence, and almost the sum, of his position. He was not concerned to uphold the dogmas of historical Christianity: the concluding stanza os In Memoriam, for example, is certainly affirmative but it does not seem to be specifically Christian.
Tennyson’s great strength, at least in the eyes of his contemporaries, was the fact that he did not ignore or reject th new theory of evolution nor any of the evidence of modern science. It is vain to search for Tennyson’s «philosophy», for he didhave one: he never arrived at any coherent system of reasonament attitudes and beliefs. At the same time, almost all his poetry is condicioned by his need to believe, his desperate search for confirmation of a faith which was always precarious though never lost. The effect is sometimes valuable, as in the visionary moment so movingly described in section xcv of In Memorian, but often the sence of being on the edge of chaos leads only to an exaggeration of familiar Victorian attitudes: one thinks, for example, of the too-strident patriotism and exaltation of war found in Maud; of his frequent celebrations of Victorian family life and of male superiority; and of his rather chilling insistence on the qualities of «Self-reverence. self-knowledge, self-control» in the presentation of such heroes as King Arthur.
Tennyson: A Critical Appreciation
Sir Harold Nicolson and F.L. Lucas, both of whom praise the early Tennyson at the expense of the later and take Somersby and Farringford as symbols of the two phases in the poet’s career. Nicolson concludes his study by firmly rejecting Tennyson the Laureate in favour of Tennyson the «morbid and unhappy mystic», the sensitive, subjective poet of loneliness and despair. Tennyson was probably only fourteen when he wrote these lines from his verse-play The Devil and the Lady. What Tennyson exhibits in his early verse is simply an instinctive feeleng for rhythm and movement, a marvellousresponsiveness and opennes to language and its metaphorical possibilities, an exuberant telent which is the more obvious for its spontaneity and lack of sophistication.
«Ulysses», the greatest of the poems first printed in 1842, yet it is hard to accept the poem as quite the unqualified assertion of purposeful optimism that it is generally taken to be. Tennyson, it is true, said that «Ulysses» was ‘ written soon after Arthur Hallam’s death, and it gives the feeling about the need of goingforward and braving the struggle of life perhaps more simply that anything in In Memorian‘ and there is no doubt an allusion to Hallam, and one which is all the more moving for its simplicity and reticence, in the reference to ‘the great Achilles, whom we knew’. But «Ulysses»is a dramatic monologue, not a statement by Tennyson in his own person, and that fact must never be lost sight of. «Ulysses» is magnificent in the simplicity and dignity of the language and the absolute assurance of the verse movement, and it emerges as a splendid and heroic figure.
TENNYSON. New Oxford English series.Michael Millgate. Oxford University Press. 1983
Academic year 2010/2011
© a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Mª Amparo Domenech Casañ
mamdoca@alumni.uv.es

Leave a Reply