R. W. Hill Jr.
The Darwinian Hypothesis – that man and ape were biologically descended from some common ancestor – was a hard pill for the Victorians to swallow. Well before The Origin of Species appeared, however, they had already become highly sensitized to any association between animal and human behavior, particularly of a sexual nature.
First, though, I should say that I am not unaware of current or past indictments of attempting just what Ishall attempt here. Tennyson one responsed to a hostile,ad hominem attack on his poem Maud – «Adulterer I may be, fornicator I may be, murderer I may be, suicide, I am nor yet.»
What set me to this task is a single sentence from Robert Wright’s The Moral Animal (1994), a book on the ne science of revolutionary psychology: «Some of the consevative norms that prevailed in Victorian England reflect, if obliquely, a surer grasp of human nature than has prevailed in the social sciences for most of this century.» Wright goes on to assert that «the resurgement moral conservatism of the past decade, especially in the realm of sex, rests on an implicit rediscovery of truths about human nature that long been denied». Sexual selection, again in Darwin’s words, is «the struggle between the individuals of one sex, generally the males, for the possession of the other sex. The result is not death to the unsuccessful competitor, but few or no offspring», i.e., what we know as genetic death.
Mankind may have evolved physically from the lower species, but at some point God had entered in and invested human beings with souls, that which distinguishes our conduct from the amorality of the other beasts that take their «licence in the field of time» unfettered by a moral sense. «No evolutionist,» Tennyson once said to Tyndall, «is able to explain the mind of Man or how any physiological change of tissue can produce conscious thought.» To Darwin’s horror, no less a scientist than Wallace himself, co-inventot of the theory of evolution, agreed with Tennyson. Natural selection, Wallace wrote, could account for the human brain, an event that called for divine intervention.
The universe or Nature has no prior or conscious design for itself an there is no God – no father figure in the sky or anywhere else. The question that haunts Tennyson’s great elegy for Hallam, «Are God and Nature then at strife?» is irrelevant, on both counts. Of course, «we long for a parent to care for us, to forgive us our errors, to save us from childish mistakes. But knowledge is preferable to ignorance. Better by far to embrace the hard truth than a reassuring fable.»
Fundamentally, what Tennyson’s lines are addressing is respect – the Victorian husband’s respect for his wife as a person and as mother of his children. Whatever his lapses of the flesh, his respect for the person of his wife was spiritually etched in granite – permanent, unequivocal, the famale’s greatest single asset in a male. True enough, the Victorians believed there were innate defferences between men and women, but the last thought a Victorian male ever had was of his wife as a sexual object for conquest.
Tennyson’s Poetry. Edited by Robert W. Hill, Jr. A Norton Critical Edition.London-New York, 1998.
Academic year 2010/2011
© a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Mª Amparo Domenech Casañ
mamdoca@alumni.uv.es

Leave a Reply