James Spedding
Th decade during which Mr Tennyson has remained silent has wrought a great improvement. The handling in his latr pieces is much lighter and freer; the interest deeper and purer; -thereis more humanity with les imagery and drapery; a closer adherence to truth; a greater reliance for effect upon the simplicity of nature. Moral and spiritual traits of character are more dwelt upon, in place of external scenery and circumstance. He addresses himself more to the heart, and less to the ear and eye. This change, which is felt in its results throughout the second volume, may in the later half of the first be traced in its process. The poems originally published in 1832, are many of them largely altered; generally with great judgement, and always with a view to strip off redundancies – to make the expression simpler and clearer, to substitute thought for imagery, and substance for shadow. The human soul, in its infinite variety of moods and trials, is his favourite haunt; nor can he dwell long upon any subject, however apparently remote from the scenes and objects of modern sympathy, without touching some string which brings it within the range of our common life.
There are four poems in which Mr Tennyson has expressly treated of certain morbid states of the mind; and from thes we may gather, not indeedhis creed, but some hints concerning his moral theory of life and its issues, and of that which constitutes a sound condition of the souk. These are the «Palace of Art» the «St Simeon Stylites», the «Two Voices», and the «Vision of Sin». The «Palace of Art» represents allegorically the condition of a mind which, in the love of beauty and the triumphant consciousness of knowledge and intellectual supremacy, in the intense enjoyment of its ownpower and glory has lost sight of its relation to man and to God.
As the «Palace of Art» represents the pride of voluptuous enjoiment in its moblest form, the «St Simeon Stylites» represents the pride of asceticism in its basest. To shadow forth dramatically the faith, the feelings, and the hopes, which support the man who, being taught that the rewards of another life will be proportioned to the misery voluntarily undergone in this, is best on qualifying himself for the best place – appears to be the design, or the running idea, of the poem.
In the «Two Voices» we have a history of the agitations, the suggestions, and counter-suggestions, of a mind sunk in hopeless despondency, and meditating self-destruction; together with the manner of its recovery to a more healthy condition. Though not one of the most perfect, it is one of the most remarkable of Mr Tennyson’s productions. An analysis of the arguments urged on either side, would present nothing very new or striking; and in point of poeticalmanagement – though rising occasionally into passages of great power and beauty, and though indicating throughout a subtle and comprehensive intellect, well fitted for a certain tender and passionate eloquence, hardly compatible with that dreary and barren misery in which the mind is supposed to be languishing. The dry and severe style with which the poem begins, should have been kept up, we think, through the greater portion of the dialogue, especially on the part of the ‘dull and bitter’ voice, which sustains the character of a tempting Mephistopheles.
The «Vision of Sin» touches upon a more awful subjet than any of these;- the end, here and hereafter, of the merely sensual man. Then follows a passage of great lyrical power, representing, under the figure of Music, the gradual yielding up of the soul to sensual escitement, in its successive stages of languor, luxury, agitation, madness, and triumph. Thisis the sensual life to which the youth is supposed to be given up. Meantime, the inevitable, irrevocable judgement comes slowly on, – not without due token and warning, but without regard.
We cannot conclude without reminding Mr Tennyson, that highly as we value the Poems which he has prodeced, we cannot accept them as a satisfactory account of the gifts which they show that he possesses; any more than we could take a painter’s collection of studies for picture, in place of the picture itself.
Tennyson’s Poetry. Edited by Robert W. Hill, Jr. A Norton Critical Edition.London-New York, 1998.
Academic year 2010/2011
© a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Mª Amparo Domenech Casañ
mamdoca@alumni.uv.es

Leave a Reply