John Stuart Mill
Of all the capacities of a poet, that which seems to have arisen in Mr. Tennyson, and in wich he most excels, is that of scene-painting, in the higher sense of the term: not the mere power of producing that rather vapid species ofocmposition usually temed descriptive poetry – for there is not in these volumes one passage of pure description; but the power of creating scenery, in keeping with some state of human feeling; so fitted to it as to be the embodied symbol of it, and to summon up the state of feeling itself, with a force not to be surpased by anything but reality. Our first specimen, selected from the earlier of the two volumes, will illustrate chiefly this quality os Mr. Tennyson’s productions. We do not anticipate that this little poem will be equally relished at first by all lovers of poetry: and, indeed, if it were, its merit could be but of the humblest kind; for sentiments and imagery which can be received at once, and with equal ease, into every mind, must necessarily be trite. Neverless, we do not hesitate to quote it at full length. The subject is Mariana, the Mariana of «Measure for Measure», living deserted and in solitude in the «moated grange».
The nominal subject excites anticipations which the poem does not even attempt to fulfil. The humblest poet who is a poet at all, could make more than is here made of the situation of a maiden abandoned by her lover. But that was not Mr. Tennyson’s idea. The love-story is secondary in his mind. The words, «he cometh not», are almost the only words which allude to it at all. To place ourselves at the right point of view, we must drop the conception of Shakespeare’s Mariana, and retain only that of a «moated grange», and a solitary dweller within it, forgotten by mankind. And now see whether poetic imagery ever conveyed a more intense conception of such a place, or of the feeling of such an inmate. From the very
first line, the rust of age and the solitude of desertion are on the whole picture. Words surely never excited a more vivid feeling of physical and spiritual dreariness: and not dreariness alone – for that might be felt under many other circumstances of solitude – but the dreariness which speaks not merely of being far from human converse and sympathy, but of being deserted by it.
Every line suggests so much more than it says, that much may be left unsaid: the concentration, which is the soul of narrative, is obtained without the sacrifice of reality and life. Where the march of the story requires that the mind shall pause, details are specified; where rapidity is necessary, they are all brought before us at a flash. Except that the versification is less exquisite, the «Lady of Shallot» is entitled to a place by the side of «The Ancient Mariner» and «Christabel.»
The poems which we have quoted from Mr. Tennyson prove incontestably that he possesses, in an eminent degree, the natural endowment of a poet – the poetic temperament. Mr. Tennyson may not be conscious of the wide difference in maturity of intellect, which is apperent in his various poems. Though he now writes from grater fulness and clearness of thoght, it by no means follows that he has learnt to detect the absence of those qualities in some of his earlier effusions. Indeed, he himself in one of the most beautiful poems of is first volume (though, as a work of art, very imperfect), the «Ode to Memory», confesses a parental predilection for the «first born» of his genius.
The poems we have quoted, we may refer, in that volume, to those entitled, «Recollections of the Arabian Nights», «The Dying Swan», «The Kraken», «The Sleeping Beauty», the beatiful poems (songs they are called, but are not), «In the glooming light», and «A spirit haunts the year’s last hours», are (like the «Mariana») not mere pictures, but states of emotion, embodied in sensuous imagery. From these, however, to the command over the materials of outward sense for the purpose of bodying forth states of feeling, evidenced by some of the poems in the second volume, especially «The Lady of Shallot» and «The Lotos Eaters», there is a considerable distance; and Mr. Tennyson seems, as he proceeded to have raised his aims still higher, to have aspired to render his poems not only vivid representations of spiritual states, but symbolical of spiritual truths. His longest poem, «The Palace of Art», is an attempt of this sort.
Academic year 2010/2011
© a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Mª Amparo Domenech Casañ
mamdoca@alumni.uv.es

Leave a Reply