Eve Kosofsy Sedgwick
Tennyson’s Princess: One Bride for Seven Brothers
It has seemed easiest for critical consensus to interest itself in the Gothic on «privete» terms and in mainstream Victorian fictions on «public» terms; but just as the psychological harrowings of the Gothic are meaningful only as moves in a public discourse of power allocation, so the avertly public, ideologycal work of writers like Tennyson, Thackeray, and elliot needs to be explicated in the supposedly intrapsychic terms of desire and phobia to make even its political outlines clear.
One important feature of the myth porpounded in The Princess‘s inner narrative is that it traces the origin of nineteenth-centurybourgeois gender arrangements directly back to the feudal aristocracy. In The Princess the Prince is an authentic liberal. His tactic in response to his father here is tp present Priness Ida’s feminism as a mirror-image extreme of his father’s crudely patriarchal style, and himself as forging a new dialectic between them, arriving at the moderating terms of a compromise. Finding one new order or new dialect, or preventing it: since one wayof describing the Prince’s erotic strategy is that, while maintaining the strict division of power and privilege between male andfemale, he favors (and permits to himself) a less exclusive assignment of «masculine» and «femenine» personal traits between men and women, in order that, as an «effeminized» man, he may be permitted to retain the privileged status of baby (within arigidly divided family)along with the implicit empowerment of maleness. In short, the Prince’s strategy for achieving his sexual ends in battle differs from his father’s only in a mirror, stylistic detail: he gets what he wants by losing the battle, not by winning it.
Similarly, as in Tennyson’s own life, the giving of a sister in marriage to cement the love of the brother for another man is central in this narrative. Although romantic love is exalted in the Prince’s view, as it is not in his father’s, nevertheless its tendency in the mythic narrative must always be to ratify and enforce the male traffic in women, not to subvert it.
This emphasis on a chivalric code in which women are «priveleged» as the passive, exalted objects of men’s intercourse with men, is part of the point of drawing a genealogy stright from the Victorian bourgeois famaly to the medievalistic courtly tradition.
To cast the narrative in terms of a “Prince” and a “Princess” is both a conventional, transparent fairytale device, and a tendentious reading of history that accomplishes several simplifying purposes. First, it permits a view of the Victorian middle-class family that denies any relation between its structure and its economics functions. By making the persistence and decadence of a stylized aristocratic family look like a sufficient explanation for contemporary middle-class audience both its historical ties to the working class and also the dregree to which, while nominally the new empowered class or new aristocracy, most of the middle class itself functions on a wage system for males and a system of domestic servitude for females. Even though the fit between the structure of the ideologically normative family and the needs of capital for certain forms of labor-power is anything but seamless, nevertheless the new middle-class family reflects these imperatives in its structure at least as strongly as it reflects internal contradictions left over from the aristocratic family of feudal times. Thus, the appeal to high chivalry obscures the contemporary situation by glamorizing and in fact dehistoricizing it.
As we will see, though, the mock-heraldry of tracing the bourgeois family back to aristocratic origins in feudal society is not the only ideologically useful way of legitimating it.
Why then is Tennyson’s defense of contemporary social arrangements in The Princess cast in the archaizing, aristocratic mold? It is through this question, I think, that we can move to a consideration of the fascinating frame narrative of the poem. For the poem takes place in a very particular England of the present (i.e., 1847), an England that, which Tennysonian daring, seems almost to represent a simple projection into the present of the inner narrative’s fantasy of a feudal past. Like Wive and Daughters, The Princess begins on a great estate, on the day of the year on which it is opened up to the tenantry and neighborhood.
The assertion that science, or technology is the legitimate offspring of patronage and connoisseurship, that all these pursuits are harmonious, disinterested, and nationally unifying, that the raison d’etre of the great landowners is to execute most impartially a national consensus in favor of these obvious desiderata – the frame narrative assumes these propositions with a confidence that is almost assaultive.
Along with the breathtaking ellipsis with which class conflict is omitted from Tennyson’s England, the aristocratic-oriented view of progress-as-patronage affects the gender politics of the poem is a recognizable, searching, and, in its own terms, radical feminism. Some of the elements of it that are taught or practiced at the University include separatism, Lesbian love, a re-vision in female-centered terms of Western history, mythology, and art, a critique of Romantic love and themale traffic in women, and a critique of the specular rationalism of Western medical science.
I am suggesting, of course, that its weakness is precisely the poem’s vision of social change as something that occurs from the top down. For Princess Ida’s relation to the University and in fact to the whole progress of feminism in the mythical southern kingdom is only an intensification of Sir Walter’s relation to “progress” among his tenants: she is the founder, the benefactor, the theorist, the historian, and the beau ideal of a movement whose disinterested purpose is to liberate them, to educate them.
Tennyson’s Poetry. Edited by Robert W. Hill, Jr. A Norton Critical Edition.London-New York, 1998.
Academic year 2010/2011
© a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Mª Amparo Domenech Casañ
mamdoca@alumni.uv.es

Leave a Reply